Goalies are very valuable in a league I'm in (six of the 12 categories are goalie cat's : w, ga, gaa, sv, sv% and shutouts).  Stupid set up, but I disgress.

Currently I only have Roloson and Neuvirth in net.  Yeah, not good.  Lucky for me I have the #1 waiver priority and there are two starters available.  Unlucky for me they are Mike Smith and Jose Theodore.

I don't really like either of them but I figure Smith has a bit more upside as Dave Tippett is a pretty strong defensive coach.

Who do you think I should pick up?